We all know the value of feedback (although we all struggle to provide it with consistency and rigor). At our last EdScale retreat, we reviewed our core values of ease, fun, and impact, and then our continued emphasis on embracing learning through mistakes. In fact, feedback is the biggest gift you can give to someone in support of their growth and learning. We learn through mistakes — even the best NBA basketball players EVER miss more than 50% of their shots, but they just keep shooting (or as Dory adopts the mantra in Finding Nemo, “Just keep swimming”).
Today, we are exploring the curiosity part of relationships, coaching, and negotiation through a simple yet effective strategy to increase opportunities for the gift of feedback: J-A-T Theory.
What is J-A-T Theory?
We’ve discussed many times on the blog (including on our last post about transitions) that humans are prediction machines; we just aren’t that great at it. So how do we hedge against our predictions while increasing the trust and value we have for our teammates and partners?
In comes J-A-T theory. J-A-T Theory came about through coaching our partners during the 2023-2024 school year. After reading “The Coaching Habit” by Michael Bungay Stainer, I leaned into leveraging more questions to coach partners and my team (see blog post for more detail).
I found myself saying session after session with incredible partners, what don’t you “Just Ask Them?” For example:
Team Member
- Do you wish you have more business partners to support awareness, exploration, and internships in growth industries? Just Ask Them.
- Do you wonder how that lesson landed with students? Just Ask Them.
Colleague/Partner
- Do you think your colleague is stressed about the new role and responsibilities, but you’re not sure how to support them? Just Ask Them.
- Do you wonder why your partners aren’t engaged in this new project? Just Ask Them.
People Manager
- Do you wonder what impact the transitions are having on your team? Just Ask Them.
- Do you wish your supervisor would listen more and support in targeted areas? Just Ask Them.
What enables deploying J-A-T Theory?
“The Trusted Advisor” emphasizes that becoming a trusted advisor requires more than expertise—it involves earning trust through relationships built on credibility, reliability, intimacy, and self-orientation.

- Credibility: Demonstrating expertise and honesty.
- Reliability: Consistently following through and keeping promises.
- Intimacy: Creating comfort, empathy, and genuine connection.
- Self-orientation: Focusing less on your own agenda, and more on the client’s needs (the lower, the better).
This approach is similar to those discussed more recently in “Radical Candor,” which combines caring personally while challenging directly to build trust through honest feedback and authentic relationships. And similar to those in “The JOLT Effect,” in helping people move through risk aversion to take action.
Take the next step
The next time you reflect on a conversation you just had and say “I wish I had asked them…”, resolve to use J-A-T theory in your next interaction. And write down the question — and go back and ask them! It’s that easy.
Worst case scenario you realize you haven’t built enough trust (see formula above to increase your values). Best case scenario, you break through a great idea that will move work forward and get better results for students.






