The district team sat across from the principal and her instructional leadership team. On one side of the table: early literacy data showing second-graders finally reading on grade level at rates the school hadn’t seen in five years. On the other side: a budget memo. Three positions eliminated. Title I allocation reduced. A curriculum training and coaching contract up for renewal at 18% more than last year. The literacy coach leaned forward. “So — what do we keep?”
That question is playing out in schools across the country right now. And the answer will determine whether hard-won student gains survive the next fiscal year — or quietly disappear.
The Budget Squeeze
School and district leaders entering SY26-27 face a convergence of fiscal pressures unlike anything in recent memory. Federal funding is contracting — the ESSER cliff has arrived, and Title program allocations face continued uncertainty. State and local revenues are tightening as pandemic-era surpluses dry up. Meanwhile, costs keep climbing: salaries, benefits, transportation, and instructional materials all cost more than they did two years ago.
The school in the opening scene didn’t get those literacy results by accident. They got them through deliberate, research-backed choices sustained over multiple years. Cutting without a framework puts all of that at risk.
So how do you protect the strategies driving results when the money shrinks? The answer rests on three legs.
Leg 1: Start with What the Research Says You Should Protect
When resources tighten, the first question should be: what does the evidence say is non-negotiable?
In early literacy, the research base is remarkably clear. High-quality instructional materials (EdReports, CCSSO HQIM networks), structured literacy approaches grounded in the science of reading, validated screening tools, and aligned professional learning (Learning Forward) produce results. The What Works Clearinghouse and the Education Endowment Foundation provide accessible, evidence-rated guidance on what moves student outcomes. Reports like TNTP’s The Opportunity Myth and Carnegie’s The Elements document what curriculum-based professional development looks like when done well. RAND’s IMPD research and tools from UnboundEd offer practical implementation frameworks. The Annenberg Math Pathways Evidence Hub extends this thinking beyond literacy.
If your early literacy gains are built on vetted materials, strong coaching, and structured professional learning, the evidence says: protect those. They’re working for a reason.
Leg 2: Use Implementation Science to Decide How
Knowing what works isn’t enough. How you implement determines whether it survives a budget cut.
Implementation quality is what separates programs that stick from programs that collapse when resources shift. Leaders need an implementation health lens — a way to assess which initiatives are mature enough to sustain with lighter support and which are still fragile. Tools like EdScale’s Implementation Health Assessment (a 14-question diagnostic framework), improvement science methods from the Carnegie Foundation, the Institute for Healthcare Improvement’s continuous improvement frameworks, and Learning Forward’s professional learning standards all provide structured ways to evaluate where you are.
Back at that table with the principal and ILT, the question isn’t just “what do we cut?” It’s: which of our initiatives have reached a point where they can sustain with less direct support — and which are mid-implementation, gaining traction, and would collapse without continued investment?
Leg 3: Let the Budget Serve the Plan — Not Replace It
Too often, fiscal constraints become the de facto strategic plan. Budget lines get cut based on funding streams, not based on evidence or implementation health. The result is incoherence: a curriculum without the coaching to support it, or a coaching model without the materials it was designed around.
Howard County Public Schools Superintendent William Barnes framed this shift well during his FY27 budget presentation, describing “a deliberate shift away from managing the budget to accommodate fiscal realities, towards leveraging the budget as a strategic tool to advance our vision for all students.” That’s the mindset more districts need right now. (Hear more from Supt. Barnes on navigating strategy and resource strategy on episode 29 of Implement. Change in Education podcast.)
Fiscal decisions should flow from your research and implementation priorities, not override them. Organizations like Education Resource Strategies and fiscal research from Georgetown University offer frameworks for aligning spending to strategy — including cost-effectiveness analysis, multi-year fiscal planning, and navigating categorical funding requirements across Title funds, state allocations, and local budgets.
What’s at Stake
The principal and ILT in that meeting didn’t build their school’s literacy results in one year. It took three years of consistent investment in materials, training, coaching, and data use. One misaligned budget cycle could unwind it.
Schools that cut without a framework — without grounding decisions in research, implementation health, and fiscal alignment — risk losing years of hard-won progress. Schools that plan with this three-legged approach can protect what matters most, even when the money shrinks.
So here’s the question: Where do you go for research, implementation, or fiscal insights when the budget memo lands? If you’re navigating this right now — figuring out what to protect, what to cut, and how to keep student growth moving forward — I’d love to hear how you’re approaching it. Hit reply and let me know.






